Background:
I have been riding for approximately 25 years and recently retired my horse. I have always ridden English type horses (Arabs, saddlebreds, etc) either huntseat or saddleseat. I haven’t ridden alot in the last 5 years because I had my daughter. My horse is retired now and I just started riding a horse for a lady that used to give me lessons about 10 years ago (free lease situation since I can’t afford board for yet another horse). In the last few years I haven’t ridden a lot of different horses or shown much.
Question/issue:
The way I ride, and have always ridden, is that you get the horse collected (round/in frame) before you ask for for an upward transition to a trot or canter. This horse I’m riding now is an Appy and I’m not real familiar with how the Western type breeds are trained (AQHAs). The riding instructor said that I should get her into the trot and then get her to be collected. When I do this, her head is always straight up and has her trot isn’t consistent. I’m having issues with her training methods because I feel that the horse should always be in frame/rounded when you are working them. After a good ride, I’ll praise the horse and let him hang his head and relax.
I’ve never seen the horse ridden by anyone else, just free lunged by the trainer (not collected at all). When I was riding her, the trainer says that she usually isn’t like that (head up/inconsistent). Is it my riding?
Any input/advice??? After my ride, I’m not really confident in my riding abilities since I haven’t shown/ridden alot of other horses in the past 5 yrs.
If you’ve mostly ridden arabs, saddlebreds, and the like, chances are you are holding your hands too high for an appy. They carry their heads quite a bit lower, and if your hands are in the usual saddle seat position, it’s gonna feel to them like you want them to lift their heads – which is exactly what you’re describing.
I collect for the canter; I’m a lot more relaxed for the trot (some collection, of course). Again, this may be the difference between someone who rides mostly saddleseat and someone who mostly rides huntseat. Even when you rode hunt seat you probably did the more upright huntseat that saddleseat type horses/riders do, just as QH riders tend to do the more WP huntseat, low and loose. Saddleseat horses are expected to be more showy in the trot, which requires more collection. The appy isn’t used to it. I know my QH, when I collect at the walk, immediately thinks "canter!" even though I may just want a collected walk, or a collected trot, or whatever. Likewise, the appy isn’t sure what you want.
Give it some time. The two of you may make a great team, once you figure out how to communicate. It’s not that you’ve lost your abilities, it’s just that your horse doesn’t read the same language your old horse did. It should come fairly quickly, as you learn what the horse can and can’t do and the horse learns to read your slightly different cues.
It’s not you. It’s not the horse. It’s the communication, and you will very quickly get that back. Good luck!